Article image
Family Law

In Practice: Sara Kitaeff

Multiple Authors

In Practice is a series in which Rubin Rudman attorneys speak candidly about the experience and judgment that shape their approach to client work.

Divorce often asks clients to make tough decisions about their children and their financial future at the same time, and at one of the hardest moments of their lives. In this installment, hear from Sara Kitaeff, a partner in Rubin Rudman’s Family Law group, on managing high-conflict cases, how her work as a court-appointed Guardian ad Litem informs the advice she gives her own clients, and what clients should understand about protecting inheritances, dividing equity compensation, and revisiting support after a divorce.

“High-conflict” is a term people use loosely. In your practice, what makes a case high-conflict, and how does that shape your decision about whether to pursue settlement or prepare for trial?

High-conflict divorce cases are a regular part of my practice. Divorces can be emotional, but conflict tends to escalate around two issues: children and the division of significant assets. When children are involved, parents may not see eye to eye on an appropriate parenting plan or may have difficulty agreeing on what is best for their children’s education and medical care.

Even in high-conflict cases, settlement is my first goal: it’s usually more cost effective, more efficient than litigation, and helps the parties maintain control over family-related decisions that, more often than not, a judge shouldn’t be making. At the same time, I prepare every case as though it may go to trial, and every strategic decision is made with trial in mind. There are discovery deadlines that need to be met for the formal exchange of information and documents, and my clients need to be ready if an out-of-court resolution is not possible.

 

 

You serve as outside general counsel for many of your clients, which means you’re in the room for both the everyday questions and the career-defining transactions. How does that ongoing relationship change the advice you give compared to being brought in for a single deal?

Serving as a Guardian ad Litem (GAL) provides me a valuable perspective that shapes how I guide my own clients through the process. I can better advise them on whom to choose for collateral contacts (the teachers, pediatricians, family members, and others a GAL interviews), how to prepare for their own interviews, and even how to introduce the GAL’s role to their children. Having firsthand experience with the process, I know what actually helps a parent’s case and what works against it. A common mistake try to help my clients avoid is being overly confrontational or defensive during a GAL investigation.

Issues of legal and physical custody are deeply sensitive, and I aim to guide clients to not point fingers, but rather recognize their own struggles as a parent and as a divorcing spouse and to acknowledge some of the challenges the other party may be facing during the divorce process. Humanizing this conversation can be incredibly helpful and will usually demonstrate to the GAL how caring and concerned a parent is for their children.

Questions about a parent’s mental health, as well as a child’s mental health, arise frequently in custody disputes, and you’ve handled matters involving psychotherapist-patient privilege, which can determine whether a child’s therapy records can be accessed, reviewed and potentially used in court. How do courts weigh mental health in parenting decisions, and what should a parent in that situation understand from the outset?

In my experience, judges are patient and respectful when divorcing parents are dealing with mental health concerns – whether those concerns involve a child or a parent. The two situations raise different questions.

When the concern involves a child, the court’s focus is always on what is in the child’s best interests. A child’s conversations with their therapist are protected by the psychotherapist-patient privilege, so the therapy records cannot simply be turned over to a parent or the court. Instead, the court may appoint a GAL to decide whether waiving that privilege serves the child’s best interest. When the privilege is waived, it is often helpful to review the child’s therapy records and have a GAL interview the therapist. That information gives the court a clearer picture of the child’s needs when it determines an appropriate arrangement for legal and physical custody.

When the concern involves a parent’s mental health, the court needs to understand how it might affect the parent’s ability to care for and make decisions for their child and to make their own financial decisions. My best advice to attorneys with parent clients in this situation is not to hide from a diagnosis or become defensive. Instead, acknowledge the concern, identify the symptoms, and understand whether and how the parent’s decision-making abilities might be affected. Then use that information to get the medical and legal assistance they need to navigate what can be a stressful and complicated situation.

If a parent’s mental health concerns relate to their ability to care for themselves, make appropriate decisions about their finances, or raise questions about their  legal competency, they may need a guardian or conservator. That’s outside my family law practice, but Rubin Rudman’s Fiduciary Litigation team practices in the Probate and Family Court and can step in when these concerns arise.

 

PRACTICAL GUIDANCE

Let’s Connect

For many executives, stock options and restricted stock units make up much of their wealth, yet these holdings may not vest until years after a divorce, and their eventual value is uncertain. How do you determine what portion is marital property, and how do you divide something no one can yet value?

The answer depends on when the equity was granted and what it represents. Usually, we divide the options or units that were granted during the marriage as marital assets, using the Baccanti formula. (I’m referring to Baccanti v. Morton, a 2001 decision of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court. In simplified terms, the formula looks at how much of each grant’s vesting period falls within the marriage and treats that share as marital property.) To apply it, we need the vesting schedule showing when each option or unit was granted and when each will vest in order to calculate the division between the parties.

Generally, any equity compensation that is granted post-divorce can be incorporated into a support calculation. However, this all depends on what the equity comp actually represents. If it’s part of a party’s compensation, it would likely be treated as income for purposes of child support or alimony. However, these grants could be provided to a party because of an ownership interest in the company, which might then be considered a post-divorce asset, which that party would likely keep.

In Massachusetts, an inheritance isn’t automatically protected in a divorce, yet you have helped clients keep one out of the division of marital property. What determines whether an inheritance stays separate, and what can someone do now to protect theirs?

The most important thing someone can do is negotiate and sign a prenuptial agreement before the marriage (or a postnuptial agreement after the marriage if a prenup was not possible). The agreement should identify and protect potential future inheritance and/or any trust distributions as separate property that will not be subject to division in the event of a divorce. Without such an agreement, the next best step is to keep an inheritance in a separate account and to avoid mixing those funds with money in a joint account.

Even so, keeping funds separate is not a guarantee. Determining whether and how an inheritance should be divided often requires a closer look at the facts: Did the parties anticipate receiving a large inheritance? Did they spend more or save less than they otherwise would have because they expected it? Was it relied on or accessed during the marriage? Even if kept in a separate account, were the funds ever used to pay for marital expenses? When was the inheritance received? These factors, among others, determine the strength of a party’s argument for keeping an inheritance separate and not divided in the event of a divorce.

Alimony and child support orders can be revisited after a divorce is final. When one former spouse receives a significant windfall, such as a new job with a substantial increase in compensation, the sale of a company or a stock option payout, how might that affect existing support obligations?

I feel like a bit of a broken record, but it depends. It can depend on whether the receipt of this “windfall” is considered income and what created it. Generally speaking, income generated from the sale of an asset that was divided in the divorce will not be included in the calculation of support, particularly if the separation or divorce judgement says so. That protection may apply only to alimony, however, and not to child support, because the definition of income for purposes of calculating child support is essentially unlimited.

Similarly, if a party acquires an interest in a business after the divorce using their income or assets they kept in the divorce, the proceeds from an eventual sale might not be considered income for support, though this is not guaranteed. Compensation from a new job, by contrast, is usually treated as income and subject to support. A stock option payout might be treated as income for support or, it could have been built into a Baccanti analysis (as noted above) and part of a division of options or shares that were granted during the divorce which would then not subject to a support calculation because those shares were already divided as assets.

For anyone concerned about their financial exposure after a divorce, the most important step is to address these scenarios during settlement negotiations and in drafting the agreement, assuming the case can be resolved outside of court. Identifying and planning for these situations in advance can provide the clarity someone needs when one actually arises.